File № 2024.0120 Classification: Star Trek · Klingons

The Unnoticed Triumph In Lower Decks: How Klingons Were Fixed While Fans Missed It

Filed
Jan 20, 2024
Read time
2 min
Franchise
Star Trek
Filed by
James Chambers
The Unnoticed Triumph In Lower Decks: How Klingons Were Fixed While Fans Missed It

Summary of findings

One cave scene in Lower Decks' The Inner Fight fixes the Klingons. Ma'ah sees Mariner's Academy friend Sito Jaxa as a warrior for standing by her convictions, and tells Mariner to honor her: slay your enemies, and study your plants.

The Klingons might be the most inconsistently written species in Star Trek. In the Original Series they were mostly a villain for the Federation to push against, the films started turning them into a real culture, and from there they drift in and out of greatness. This file is about one short scene in Lower Decks that gets them right, and what it says about honor.

Spoilers ahead for Lower Decks season 4, including where Mariner's story has been heading for several seasons.

The scene

Mariner has been taking bigger and bigger risks, and she ends up in a fight with a Klingon named Ma'ah. When the sky starts raining glass, they take cover in a cave together and start talking. She tells him she got a promotion she didn't want and tried to get demoted.

Mariner reveals she was at the Academy with Sito Jaxa, who was posted to the Enterprise and later killed on a covert mission. Mariner idolized her. The Inner Fight, Lower Decks season 4

When Ma'ah hears "Enterprise," his whole attitude changes. He knows the stories. Mariner only sees the ship that got her friend killed. He sees the whole record of what it did.

A warrior by choice

Then they get to the Dominion War. Ma'ah wishes he could have seen it, and Mariner tells him there was no honor in it, just massacres. Starfleet is supposed to be about solving the mysteries of life, not fighting wars. That's the real divide in the scene. Ma'ah is a warrior by choice. Mariner is one by circumstance.

Ma'ah tells her Sito was a warrior and that Mariner doesn't honor her. Sito made her choice, he says, and gave her life protecting the kind of Starfleet Mariner says she believes in. The Inner Fight, Lower Decks season 4
Look at what Ma'ah actually knows about Sito. She died on a covert job, not in a glorious last stand. What earns his respect is that she stood by her convictions and died for others. Honor isn't always at the end of a bat'leth. Our read

"Study your plants"

Here's where Lower Decks fixes the Klingons. Ma'ah doesn't tell Mariner to go off and fight. He tells her to honor her friend, slay her enemies, and study her... what was it, plants? He's telling her to be the Starfleet officer she actually wants to be, because that's how you honor someone. That's a Klingon who understands what honor means, not just what combat looks like.

Yes, Lower Decks is a cartoon with jokes, and yes, it's adult comedy. But there's a lot of Star Trek in it, and if you haven't given it a shot, this scene is a good reason to start. Tell me below whether it won you over.