File № 2024.0727 Classification: Star Trek · Dominion War

The Dominion War's Dark Legacy in Star Trek's New Series

Filed
Jul 27, 2024
Read time
2 min
Franchise
Star Trek
Filed by
James Chambers
The Dominion War's Dark Legacy in Star Trek's New Series

Summary of findings

The darker Starfleet of Picard and Lower Decks traces back to DS9's Dominion War: Sisko poisoning a Maquis world, the Houdini mines on AR-558, Garak and In the Pale Moonlight, and Section 31's virus aimed at the Founders.

Starfleet after the Deep Space Nine era looks a lot darker than the one we knew in The Next Generation. It's more militarized, and the universe around it is grimmer. Whatever you think of the newer shows, this file argues they were all shaped by one event: the Dominion War.

Before the war

The hard fights of the 23rd century led to a fairly comfortable mid-24th century. The Klingons were allies and the Romulans had pulled back, so Starfleet could treat combat as a small part of the job. One TNG line sums it up: combat was a minor province in the makeup of a starship captain. Then the Federation met the Dominion.

Where you can see it

Lower Decks is the lightest of the newer shows, and the war is all over it. Mariner is a Dominion War veteran who hides in the lower decks to avoid facing what she lost. In Picard, Starfleet is more advanced and more armed, and Section 31 is now known well beyond a secretive few.

In The Next Generation, Starfleet was a science organization that could also fight. After the Dominion War, it became a military that does science in its spare time. Our read

A slow slide

The interesting part is the why, and it starts before the war, with the Maquis.

To force Eddington to surrender, Sisko poisons a Maquis colony world with trilithium resin, making it uninhabitable for Humans. Earlier, Sisko himself told Worf, "We don't put civilians at risk, or even potentially at risk, to save ourselves." For the Uniform, DS9 season 5; Rules of Engagement, DS9 season 4

The colonists had time to evacuate, and people defend Sisko on that point. But it's about as far from the Next Generation's Starfleet as you can get, and nothing happens to him for it. Then the war starts, and Starfleet is losing badly. For a long stretch the Federation is genuinely in danger, and the decisions get harder to defend.

On AR-558, the Starfleet defenders turn the Dominion's own "Houdini" mines against the Jem'Hadar, the same kind of ruthless weapon they'd just been fighting. The Siege of AR-558, DS9 season 7

Then there's In the Pale Moonlight, where Sisko helps bring the Romulans into the war with a forged recording, and then lives with the murders Garak commits to make it stick. And finally the morphogenic virus, built by Section 31 to wipe out the Founders.

Pale Moonlight is where Starfleet becomes a full military, willing to give up its morals to save its people even if some of its officers can't sleep at night. The virus is where the Federation lost something it never fully got back. Our read

The shadows

The DS9 finale tries to put a hopeful bow on all of it, but Starfleet was changed for good. You may not like the style or the writing of the newer shows, but the darker Starfleet they show is exactly what you'd expect from an organization that went through that war.

Did the Dominion War change everything? Tell me below.