File № 2026.1120 Classification: Battlestar Galactica · Cylons

The Cylons Built Basestars to Win One War. They Lost the Next One.

Filed
Nov 20, 2026
Read time
8 min
Franchise
Battlestar Galactica
Filed by
James Chambers
The Cylons Built Basestars to Win One War. They Lost the Next One.

Summary of findings

Battlestar Galactica's basestars from the Fall to the finale. Cavil, Natalie, Boomer, Anders, the Hybrids, Raiders and Centurions. Exodus, He That Believeth in Me, Six of One, The Hub and Daybreak.

The Cylons wiped out twelve worlds in one day. Then they spent four seasons losing. By the end of Battlestar Galactica, their last basestar flies off under the Cylons who never once got a vote. This file follows the basestar as the ship the Cylons built for one war, the Fall of the Twelve Colonies, and what happened to it when the war kept going.

One thing up front. "Won" here means the attack on the Colonies, not the First Cylon War from the Final Five video. "The next one" is everything after it: the hunt, the occupation and the civil war. When something is my read and not the show's, I'll say so.

Built for one day

The Cylons were created by man. They did the Colonies' fighting for them, then turned on them, and how the humans won that first war matters more than anything else in this file.

"Betrayed by their own technology, they fought the Cylons with weapons that didn't rely on computers." Miniseries, opening titles

Then came 40 years of peace, and the Colonies plugged everything back in. The Cylons spent those same 40 years building a new fleet, and the Cylon ships we see from the earlier war look nothing like a basestar. This ship was designed during the quiet, for the war they were planning next.

On the day of the attack, Colonial squadrons lose power just as they engage the enemy. With the defenses switched off, the basestars jump in and the nukes go out. Miniseries

Now look at the ship that did it. A basestar is a carrier and a missile platform, and it never really needs to go toe-to-toe with anyone. Its job is to show up, fill the sky with Raiders and missiles, and leave a burning target behind it.

The show never says this out loud, but this is exactly the ship you build when you expect the other side's guns to be off. It's built for reach and for numbers, all on one day. Our read

And on that day, the plan worked. Twelve worlds fell in hours. As a weapon for one war, you'd struggle to find a more successful ship in the whole show. The trouble starts the next morning.

The hunt

Not everyone was plugged in. Adama never let anyone network Galactica, so she gets away. At Ragnar, Starbuck counts two basestars and ten squadrons of Raiders, and Galactica still walks out with the civilian fleet behind her. Now the basestar fleet has a job it was never built for: chasing a target that runs, jumps and shoots back. It fits that job about as well as a cruise ship fits a car chase.

Over Kobol, Boomer flies a Raptor into a basestar, sets off a nuke inside it and gets back out. Later, Galactica and Pegasus destroy the Resurrection Ship and two basestars along with it. Kobol's Last Gleaming, season 1; Resurrection Ship, season 2

Up close against a battlestar, the basestar keeps coming off second best.

Separate ways

Then a Cavil shows up on Galactica with a message, and for once it isn't a threat. The Cylons have decided the occupation of the Colonies was a mistake. A Six and an Eight swung the vote, and the Eight is Sharon Valerii, Boomer.

"You've been given a reprieve." Cylon and man will now go their separate ways. Lay Down Your Burdens, Part II, season 2

So the Cylons won the war they built this fleet for, tried to hold on to what they won, decided it was a mistake and let the humans go. The next war got called off by the Cylons themselves, which has the energy of a very polite breakup text sent after you've already burned down the apartment.

About a year later they find the humans anyway, settled on New Caprica. When Baltar asks how, the answer is quite by accident: they picked up a nuclear detonation from more than a light-year away. The most advanced hunting fleet in the show found its target the way I find my car keys, by giving up and tripping over them.

So they occupy the planet, and it turns out running one planet is a lot harder than nuking twelve. When Baltar tells them to pack up their Centurions and leave, he gets about the most honest answer a Cylon gives all season. If they go, the humans will raise their kids on stories about the Cylons, and one day those kids will go back out into the stars and hunt them. Blood for blood, and that has to stop one day.

Four basestars, one old battlestar

Adama comes back for his people. The basestars close on two battlestars over New Caprica and find drones: "There's no Galactica and no Pegasus." The real Galactica drops out of the sky on top of them, "Altitude 99,000, falling like a rock." Four basestars come after her without fighter cover, then Pegasus arrives and three of the four are gone. Exodus, Part II, season 3

Four basestars against one battered old battlestar should be easy math. A ship built for targets with their guns off kept running into old ones that shot back, and in the end the Cylons quit the chase themselves. That's the first way they lost the next one.

The ship is the society

To see the second way, you need to know what a basestar actually is, because it isn't a ship the way Galactica is a ship. Galactica has a CIC with one person in the chair, and we spent the whole Pegasus video on what happens when the wrong person sits in it. A basestar has a Hybrid, a Cylon wired into a tank of fluid, and it runs the ship, everything from the weapons to the jumps.

The basestar being partly alive and able to heal itself comes from reference material, not from a line of dialogue. If it's true, that's more than anyone ever managed for Galactica. Reference material

The Hybrid also never stops talking, mostly in something between poetry and a broken GPS, and some Cylons treat it as close to the voice of their god.

Natalie, the Six who ends up leading the rebels: "The Hybrid is clearly telling us something." Cavil: "They're supposed to maintain operations on each ship, not vomit metaphysics." Six of One, season 4
Natalie has been shot on Galactica, and the rebel basestar jumps and jumps again with nobody aboard able to stop it. "The Hybrid is disorganized. It's panicking." And they can't unplug her, "because now she's wired herself into life support." The Hub, season 4
The Cylons decide things together, by model, and the basestar is built around that. The Hybrid flies it, the Raiders launch from it, the Centurions guard it, and it all works as one system. A battlestar has one person who decides. A basestar has everyone. And the day everyone stops agreeing, there's nobody in the chair. Our read

The Raiders say no

That day starts at the Ionian Nebula. Four basestars find the fleet and launch more than 200 Raiders. One takes out the Pyxis, and Roslin says it plainly: 600 souls on that ship. For a few minutes, the basestar is doing exactly the job it was built for.

Then a Raider gets a good look at Sam Anders, scans him with its red eye and turns away. "The Cylon strike force has just turned back to their ships. Baseships are spinning up." He That Believeth in Me, season 4

Anders is one of the Final Five, Cylons who spent their lives believing they were human. The Cylons work it out too: the Raiders refused to fight because they sensed the Final Five might be in the Colonial fleet. Picture being the Cylon in charge of that attack, and your fighters just decide they'd rather not.

The vote

Cavil's answer is to fix the weapons. The Raiders exceeded their programming, and he wants to rewire their brains. He isn't sentimental about it: they're tools, not pets. Natalie points out the catch. He can't make any change without a majority vote. So they vote by model. The Ones, Fours and Fives say yes. The Twos, Sixes and Eights say no. Deadlocked.

Then Cavil brings in Boomer. "This Eight has voted to reconfigure." Natalie: "No one has ever voted against their model. No one." Cavil: "The Raiders were designed to do a specific job. They stopped doing it. I'm fixing that." Six of One, season 4

That's this whole file in one sentence, from a Cylon leader's own mouth, and he means it as a repair order. But look at what just broke. In the same scene, one of them says their identities are determined by their models, and Boomer just voted against hers. There's no rule against it, because nobody imagined they'd need one.

Natalie's side has a different fix in mind, and it involves the one part of the basestar nobody ever asked. The Centurions do the guarding and the killing, and they've never had a vote on anything. When Cavil tells her she can't do anything without a vote, her answer, with the Centurions behind her, is that they can't do anything with one, so they're finished voting.

Basestar against basestar

The system the whole basestar was built around just ended on screen. Natalie's side took the limits off the Centurions' minds, and the first thing they learned was what Cavil was doing to the Raiders. From there, it's basestar against basestar. Cavil's ships ambush the rebels and destroy their baseships until only Natalie's badly damaged one is left, and the rebels join Galactica. A fleet built to wipe out humans is now wiping out itself.

Rebels and humans together nuke the Resurrection Hub, the thing that lets every Cylon wake up in a new body when they die, and at least one of the basestars guarding it goes with it. The Hub, season 4

The people who built a war around never having to die lost that in a war with each other. That's the second way they lost the next one.

The Cylons' best case

I've been pretty hard on the Cylons, and I'd rather not make a case that only argues with people who aren't in the room, so here's their best shot. The strongest pushback is that this was never a new war. The shooting barely stops from the Miniseries to the finale. That's a real argument. Where I hold the line is on what the Cylons wanted. They called off the hunt, tried an occupation, and by season 4 their enemy was each other. Same calendar, different war, and that framing is mine.

Second, maybe the Cylons didn't lose at all. They won the Fall, and in the end Cylons and humans made peace. That's fair for the rebels who came through it by switching sides. Cavil's Cylons, the ones who planned the attack and ran the fleet, end the show worse off than anybody.

Third, the basestar wasn't weak. Agreed, it wrecked twelve worlds. That's the point: it was excellent at its job, and it lost when the fighting turned long. And last, the humans beat them, so the Cylons' own choices don't matter. Partly true. The humans won the fights. They just weren't the ones who called the vote.

The last basestar

The last time the two sides talk, it's over Hera, the half-Cylon girl Cavil has taken to the Colony. The Final Five offer him what he lost at the Hub.

"We'll give you resurrection. But the war ends here." Humanity is left in peace, and the pursuit is given up now and for all time. Daybreak, Part II, season 4

That's the second time the Cylons agree to call off the next war, and this one doesn't outlast the episode. The deal falls apart, Cavil dies by his own hand, the Colony is lost, and the Cylons who planned the one-day war don't make it out of the long one.

The rebels who survive end up with the humans, and they don't keep the last basestar. They give it to the Centurions, the Cylons who never once got a vote, and let them go. For a show that opens with robots coming back to kill everyone, handing the robots a warship and waving goodbye is a bold way to end.

Remember what a Cylon told Baltar on New Caprica: blood for blood, and that has to stop one day. The ones who said it never managed it. The ship they built to win one day of war leaves with the only Cylons who never had a say in any of it. Our read

This is the third file in the Ships run, after Galactica Wasn't Lucky and Pegasus Wasn't Better Than Galactica, and it picks up where The Colonies Should Have Won BSG's Second Cylon War left off.

The show never puts a name on where one war ended and the next began, and I'm not going to either. Was the Cylon civil war a new war, or the same one that started with the Fall? Where would you draw the line? Tell me below.